Tags
alcoholic, ANZAC Day, Battle of Gallipoli, DNA, hamster wheel of hell, Lest we forget, mental health, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, PTSD, Rats of Tobruk, remembrance, transgenerational transmission, Trauma, WWI
Today is ANZAC Day here in Australia – which stands for Australian and New Zealand Army Corps. Essentially it’s the remembrance day for those who fought in the Battle of Gallipoli in WWI. Generally speaking however, we honour all of our armed forces on this day – those that survived as well as those that passed.
All over the country, dawn services are held. There’s also one held in Gallipoli every year which is very popular with Aussie tourists, kind of like a pilgrimage of sorts.
In yesterday’s weekend paper, there was a piece about the remnants of an army unit known as the Rats of Tobruk – The Last Rats who fought in WWII. My maternal grandfather was one of their number but unlike the men featured in the story, he passed away thirteen years ago.
This is a photo of my grandfather, taken the year he died. I so wish I had a photo of him in his army uniform when he was young – he looked so handsome back then!
There’s things I know about my grandfather that made me do a double take on each of the former soldiers featured in the article.
Like, I know that he returned an alcoholic – not an uncommon side-effect of war. Somehow, despite his daily drinking he managed 85 years before he finally succumbed to liver cancer. I was living interstate at the time but my mother told me how confused and terrified he was on his deathbed – “…he was convinced the war was still going on and he was in the bunkers, hiding from snipers…”.
One moment he’d be lucid and talking to family members and the next he was re-living the war. I also know that he saw one of his best friends get blown up in combat, and there must be other atrocities he never mentioned but lived with for most of his life.
All of this tells me that my grandfather had PTSD – before there was a recognised diagnosis for it. Without any support for his condition, alcohol became the only way to anesthetise his ongoing trauma. Of course, he wasn’t the only one.
These days soldiers coming back from the war aren’t much better off. PTSD is generally recognised now, but sufferers are still not appropriately treated. Just read this case study, which talks about the soldier’s experiences, but says almost nothing about treatment.
As well as remembering my grandfather and everyone who’s ever gone to war on behalf of their country, today I remember that some of those survivors have lived with untreated PTSD for many long decades. It breaks my heart that some of the men interviewed in The Last Rats possibly still deal with PTSD even now.
On top of that, I’ve been considering my family history of trauma. There are theories and research on something called “transgenerational transmission” of PTSD, and here’s just a few examples:
It doesn’t seem so far-fetched to imagine that changes to the brain wrought by PTSD can impact a person’s DNA, creating an inherent risk of PTSD for that person’s progeny if they too, suffer a traumatic event.
As well as my grandfather, I suspect my mother experienced it, too. In addition to being powerless to stop the adoption of her first child from proceeding (against her wishes), she almost died giving birth. And she’s mentioned things from time to time about “…not being able to stop the memories from coming back over and over…”. It’s reasonable to assume that she too, could be a PTSD sufferer. Undiagnosed and untreated, just like my grandfather.
So if there’s any truth to the research on genetic pre-disposition, what hope did my mother or I have in the face of extremely traumatic events in our lives? It certainly helps me to understand why I had such an intense reaction to a single incident of being assaulted!
But fortunately for me, I grew up embracing alternative therapies and so it wasn’t too much of a leap for me to talk to a therapist or try EMDR, which meant that I got the help I needed and ultimately, I’ve been able to free myself from the hamster wheel of hell that is PTSD. Of course, the study and treatment of PTSD have also advanced significantly in recent times.
All of this makes me think that every ANZAC Day should be a time when we also consider how war affects people’s mental health. How many returned soldiers are still suffering in silence? If as a society, we could make it okay to talk openly about mental health issues without fear of stigmatisation, it would help. I know from my own experience that silence only makes things worse, even though at the time I thought it was a way of protecting myself.
Lest we forget those who died, and those who still live in a daily personal version of hell. Love and healing to you all.
~Svasti
So many soldiers came back with PTSD and I think WW1 might have been even worse for it (didn’t they call it shell shock then?).
I agree that it is time mental health issues were spoken about more openly. There are very few people who have not had some contact with mental health issues, yet in the UK at least it is still seen as so taboo.
Yes, I too am concerned about the effect of war on peoples mental health. There are so many stories about American soldiers having difficulty on returning. Anxiety, violence, suicide are just some of the troubles.
Oh Svasti, this is SUCH a huge issue in East Timor and one that is going almost completely un-dealt with by the Government. I think that the entire population above the age of 15 or so is suffering from direct PTSD as a result of everything they lived through from 75-99. How could they not? And now they are trying to build a new nation, struggling to rise out of poverty, and it’s all just so hard… You will hear people say things like “it’s a violent culture”, or “violence is in our blood”, but in fact I believe that it’s PTSD manifesting itself when small social conflicts turn into huge blowouts (like in 2006), or on a more intimate scale, when almost every household in the country is affected by domestic violence in many forms.
It really is heartbreaking. Add to your list above not only generational transmission of PTSD but CULTURAL, inter-generational transmission. Sigh. It does my head in!
I’ve been reading your blog for awhile now and really appreciate all your inspiring words. 🙂
I am particularly interested in the article links you posted today about genetic/hereditary links to PTSD. It seems so obvious to me, but reading it with scientific information and hypotheses to back it up really lets me look at it in a whole new light. Truly I think if our world understood these facts, the consequences of our actions all around the world and how it is affecting the generations to come, maybe someday we’d have a hope of reversing some of the effects.
Thank you for this post.
Hey girl, I linked to this post today. 🙂
Pingback: Tweets that mention ANZAC Day musings « Svasti: A Journey From Assault To Wholeness -- Topsy.com
@Rachel @ Suburban Yogini – Yeah, they did used to call it shell shock! The more people talk about mental health issues, the more we’ll all realise it’s not just someone else’s issue, but something we are all impacted by.
@Brooks Hall – And the more returned soldiers who come home with PTSD, the more that impacts society as a whole. It’s such a vicious cycle if left untreated!
@LaGitane – That sounds incredible, and just so sad! Makes me wanna come over and do some yoga with you some time. Maybe a workshop for those who really need it!
@azizaafire – Thanks heaps for your comment! It’s always good to know who is reading my blog. 🙂
We can’t stop people from being traumatised, but what we can do is embrace healing and therapy far more openly. Pretty much everyone in the world is hurting emotionally in some way or another. PTSD is just more extreme, but the principal is the same for all people.
@LaGitane – Many thanks to you! 😀
hi, i was just wondering what is your grandfathers name? im writing an essay for uni about the trauma effects of gallipoli and i was just wondering if i can reference your blog as a reference
Hi Jodie, I’m sorry but you do not have my permission to use this story for your assignment.